I was hoping that you had solved your issues, but apparently not as I chanced across another reddit post 2 days ago.
Experts here have recommended using PingPlotter to find out if you have DDOS or other interruptions in your ISP’s internet service. Ping is a tool which network knowledgeable people use to determine the latency of network traffic or if packets are dropped. There are also less scientific methods to perhaps find out if you are experiencing internet service interruptions. For example, when you have a problem on your PC, what happens to a streaming show on your TV? Or other devices which you may be using when the issue occurs? If it isn’t occurring on other devices, then this may not be a WAN issue from a DDOS attack or other ISP problem.
To get to the bottom of this, will you please provide the following information and steps:
-
What type of Internet service do you have and what are the provisioned upload/download speeds; cable, fiber, DSL, Starlink or Fixed Wireless (WiFi to Verizon or T-Mobile are examples in the US)? What is the make and model number of your modem and router? If you have cable for instance, hopefully it is a DOCSIS 3.1 modem (some older DOCSIS 3.0 modems with Intel Puma chips experience delays for example).
-
How is your network wired, presumably with Ethernet cables, but perhaps something like MoCA? Do you have any switches and if so, what is the topology? How many Wi-Fi access points or extenders do you have beyond your main router if any? In particular, how is your PC connected and what operating system is it running (Windows 10 or 11?)?
-
Which devices are experiencing delays or interruptions, and are they hard wired or WiFi (if you are still using WiFi)? Do they experience issues at the same time, or are some working fine to access the internet while others are experiencing issues?
-
Assuming you have Windows on your PC, will you please bring up a CMD window and run “ping google.com -n 1000 -l 1024” (-n is the number of iterations, -l is the packet length). You will get statistics that show your Minimum latency, Maximum Latency and Average Latency, along with the number of Lost packets and percentage of Lost packets. You want zero Lost packets. If you have lost packets, then we need to track down why it is happening which usually is a WAN issue. You can run this while you are gaming or having an online meeting. However, please do not use a VPN when you are doing this (we can’t tell whether latency issues are with the VPN or the ISP, plus VPN’s can retransmit packets). High latency issues are also a problem, but can be caused by overloading your upload or download beyond the limits of your provisioned service (“bufferbloat”). Let’s see what you report.
PingPlotter remains the tool of choice for figuring out issues. It will report dropped packets, the latency of WAN traffic, and do this 24 hours a day so you can capture sporadic problems. Plus people use it as proof to their ISP that there are issues that the ISP needs to address. I believe you have tried using it. So do you have any dropped packets? Those are shown in red on the bottom timeline graph.
- Will you please explain further what these “drops” are that your ISP has verified? ISP’s normally have the capability to communicate with their modems to determine if there are signal level issues or dropouts. Is this what is happening? If so, it is the ISP’s issue (unless you have flakey power to the modem, or you are sharing a power outlet on the wall with your neighbor and he is somehow playing with your power cables). The ISP may also have the ability to communicate with their router (you may have a combined modem / router). If they do have the capability, is the router experiencing the drops while the modem doesn’t experience any drops or signal level issues, something they should be able to tell you?
Additional Comments:
-
In your recent reddit post, you said “I am looking for a device with good/enhanced security, specifically guarding against DOS attacks and also allows me to disable wireless and use LAN only.” All a router can do is ignore DDOS attack packets to ports which are not open on the router, or in some cases, let you know that a SYN attack is going on. It can’t stop the DDOS attack packets from being sent to an IP address and arriving to your router when you have that IP address, thus using up 99% of your download bandwidth. Also, every WiFi router that I am aware of, including those from ISP’s, allows you to turn of WiFi.
https://www.reddit.com/r/HomeNetworking/comments/11gegoh/secure_router_recommendations_isp_recognizes_dos/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Peplink/comments/10cirbd/ddosdos_attack_please_advise/ -
You commented that you believe the Surf Soho allows you the capability to change your router IP address. While there is a configuration option to change a static IP address, static IP’s are generally only available for business accounts, at least in the US. And even if you have a static IP address from your ISP, they assign it, not you. More than likely you have a dynamically assigned IP address (“DHCP”) from your ISP. That IP address tends to be sticky. However, turning your modem and router off for 30 minutes to 24 hours may result in getting a new IP address. Or you may be able to call your ISP and see if they will change it.
-
FYI, it is possible for there to be electromagnetic interference from your equipment or from your neighbor which can affect cable signals and equipment. Unusual but possible (did your neighbor purchased a giant magnet that he rubs against the wall…) So at some point you may want to try separating your equipment and cables from each other, and if they are on the wall next to the neighbor, away from that wall, perhaps even using a long extension power cord from another part of the house rather than power from the wall you share with your neighbor.
SG :: Short Stories and Fixes
SG :: Router speed drop solved